Texas Liberal

All People Matter

Houston Red Light Camera Ban Rejected In Federal Court—Let’s Accept The Voter’s Will With Both The Red Light Cameras And The Storm Water Fee

A federal judge has ruled that the  successful ballot issue that prohibited the City of Houston’s use of red light cameras is invalid.

(Above–A red light in Houston.) 

From the Houston Chronicle—

“U.S. District Judge Lynn Hughes ruled the city can not reverse an ordinance except by a referendum of voters held within 30 days of the passage of the ordinance. Opponents to the red light camera ordinance, which passed in 2004, mounted the last year challenge as an amendment to the city charter but Hughes said it was essentially the same thing. “Presented with this mislabeling, the council supinely ignored — over voices of some of its members — their responsibility and put the proposition to the voters,’’ Hughes ruled.”

This type of mob rule outside the process of the law reminds me of the classic book and movie about a lynch mob called The Ox Bow Incident. 

Though in this case the lynch mob took six years to form since the red light cameras were installed in Houston.

I suppose that is as clever as you can expect a lynch mob to be.

It is clear enough that the public rejected red light cameras. These cameras were on the ballot in November of 2010. The people of Houston voted by a margin of 53%-47% to get rid of the cameras.

While the ruling of the court must be respected, the City of Houston should defer to the decision at the ballot box. Mayor Annise Parker says she is considering many options about what the city should do after this ruling.

I say this as someone who very much supported the red light cameras. I believe they save lives.

(Below–Grim Reaper. Drawing by MesserWoland. )

At the same time, if we are going to go by the decision of the public about red light cameras, let us also respect the decision of the public at the ballot box about the new storm water fee.

The storm water fee was passed the same day the red light camera ban passed.

Some are now upset that the fee will be more than was claimed during the campaign. Though, since folks who backed the storm water fee want to do the right thing—if only for politcal purposes—the assessment has now been lowered.

Instead of the ceaseless harping about a fee that will help Houston deal with the serious flooding problem, let us just accept what the people decided on Election Day 2010 and move on to the next fight.

( Top Texas blogger Charles Kuffner has also written about this ruling.)  

June 18, 2011 - Posted by | Uncategorized | , , , , ,


  1. I would certainly agree that it is intuitive that red light cameras would make intersections safer, but this doesn’t appear to be the case. There are many studies that show that the presence of red light cameras increases the rate of accidents.

    Comment by David @ I Love My Gov | June 18, 2011

  2. I agree about the studies, and yet when they took them out, the number of accidents increased. Go figure.

    Comment by john cobarruvias | June 18, 2011

  3. There are differing studies. I go with the one that say the number of accidents gets reduced with the cameras. But in any case, violating traffic laws should come with a penalty. For all the talk about privacy and big brother, the real issue was that people just did not want to get the tickets after they broke the law.

    Thanks for both comments.

    Comment by Neil Aquino | June 19, 2011

  4. Actually the accidents went down after the vote banning them.. ATS and HPD had to data shop to find the “increase” they wanted by going to a previous period. It should be also noted that HPD was busted a few years back manipulating another RLC “report”. So trusting them is akin to trusting Tokyo Rose!


    (Also on the “violation” numbers ATS played games in Baytown with Rejection rates. http://www.thenewspaper.com/news/31/3173.asp Any bets the “increase” in violations are related to NO rejection rate being used).

    Fight the Scam!

    Ban the CAMS!

    RESPECT the will of the Voters!


    Comment by Stephen Donaldson | June 21, 2011

  5. The people of Houston Voted the cameras be removed. Accidents at intersections went down. Who is this judge to overrule the people’s vote? LET FREEDOM RING!!!!

    Comment by Bad Puddytat | June 25, 2011

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: